Category: PT Problem of the Day

  • PT Problem of the Day: Smartbus signs not so smart

    One of the features of Smartbus routes is the connections to other trams, buses and trains — which are essential to provide a public transport network capable of anywhere-to-anywhere travel. At some stops, the automated signs are meant to show the times of those connecting services… but don’t. These two are at Bentleigh and Bundoora…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Flinders St Station entrances close early

    The Elizabeth Street and Southbank entrances to Flinders Street Station close at 10pm, even on busy Friday and Saturday nights. Some passengers are unaware until they find the closed gate — and some decide rather than walk around, to climb over it. Passengers attempting to enter from Southbank and Elizabeth Street have to walk up…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Altona to City Loop inter-peak requires catching 3 trains

    Before May, Altona to Parliament off-peak on weekdays was a 30 minute trip with no changes. Now it’s two changes (Newport, 7 minutes, and North Melbourne, as much as 9 minutes if following the Metlink Journey Planner), for a total trip time of some 46 minutes. Connection times at Newport are worse than those formerly…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Missing stations on Southern Cross maps

    Is it unreasonable to expect that that train network maps at Melbourne’s major CBD stations should be kept up to date? This one, snapped last week, isn’t. Missing is Coolaroo station, on the Craigieburn line between Broadmeadows and Roxburgh Park. It opened just over a year ago, on 6th June 2010. Other stations have up-to-date…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Level crossing delays for passengers

    It’s not just traffic that gets delayed by level crossings. Pedestrians, including train passengers, sometimes have to wait long periods for trains to pass. Often for those trying to enter stations, it can mean the difference between making the train and missing it… never a problem at stations where the level crossing has been grade-separated.…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Public holiday timetable confusion

    If you’re catching Metro Trains or Yarra Trams today, Saturday timetables (without late-night services) apply. But what about other services, including buses? Metlink says that in Melbourne, 199 bus routes will run to Saturday times, but 21 will run to Sunday times. And one will run to a special timetable. V/Line will run most services…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Dropping the ball on football specials

    Big events — with large numbers of people leaving in a short space of time — should be what public transport do best. When crowds are expected to be leaving an MCG footy game en masse, it shouldn’t be too hard to plan to have frequent services to get them home. But as this picture…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Dirty vehicles in service

    Better to have a dirty vehicle than a cancelled service of course, but perhaps they can do better at ensuring graffiti is more efficiently cleaned-off. Help our campaign for better public transport. Join the PTUA now. We rely entirely on member funding and enthusiastic volunteers to operate. More about PT Problem Of The Day, including…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Parking in the bus stops

    How do you really rub public transport users’ noses in it? Allow parking in the bus stops. This is the outbound stop on Lonsdale Street, near Swanston Street. Outside peak times, not only does the bus lane not operate, but they actually allow cars to park right in front of the bus shelters, discouraging passengers…

  • PT Problem of the Day: V/Line train sardines

    It’s not just buses, trams and Metro trains that get packed. This picture was snapped by a PTUA member on the 4:57pm Geelong line train to Marshall. The first stop out of Melbourne to let off passengers was Little River, so passengers would have been standing for at least 43 minutes. Are you unhappy with…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Who stops cars from blocking trams?

    Priority measures such as tram lanes can help prevent delays to trams, which is important, as a single tram may be carrying hundreds of passengers. But those measures only work if they’re used properly. Just like bus lanes, they get blocked by thoughtless motorists driving and stopping where they’re not meant to — and policing…

  • PT Problem of the Day: Footscray’s bus/tram/train connections all over the shop

    Footscray is a major interchange location for the western suburbs, with passengers changing between trains, trams and buses. Despite the recent upgrade to the station, with a new multimillion dollar bridge, nothing has been done about bus stop locations, which are spread around numerous locations around the area, with some stops up to 350 metres…